What would aliens look like?
I asked whether intelligent life on another planet would follow anything like our evolutionary path, or whether humans are a one-off. Everybody who answers this question reaches for the same argument, and I reached for it too before I checked it. It is a good argument. It is also, in the specific form everyone uses, wrong. The argument everybody makes Evolution repeats itself. Give it the same problem twice and it finds the same answer twice, so the features that keep reappearing on Earth are the features we should expect anywhere. ...